I have spent the last number of years trying to tune the solar and home battery set up to ensure that I am giving PG&E as little money as possible. Seriously, that company sucks out loud. Anyways, winter is a bit challenging as my the arc of the sun no longer fully charges the battery during the day and the increased load from electric-driven heaters pushes my overall power usage out of “surplus” into “consumption.”
Most of the day the battery is in “self-consumption” mode. The house runs off whatever is available, solar first and then the battery, and the grid only fills in what is left. Nothing clever is happening there but I am trying to optimize for the cheapest power which is whatever I am pulling from the roof.
Two hours before the utility’s “partial peak” window starts, the battery switches to charge from the grid. By the time partial peak and then peak arrive the battery is full and the house draws from it instead of from the grid at the most expensive hours of the day.
The first winter season with the battery I was loathe to charge from the grid because it just felt wasteful. The math however maths in your favor for charging “off-peak”.
PG&E’s EV2-A rate, roughly speaking:
- Off-peak, midnight to 3 p.m.: $0.22558/kWh
- Partial-peak, 3 to 4 p.m. and 9 p.m. to midnight: $0.39428/kWh
- Peak, 4 to 9 p.m.: $0.41099/kWh
Those are the bundled winter rates from Electric Schedule EV2, effective June 1, 2026.
The peak power is almost 2x as expensive as the off-peak at any point between midnight and 3pm. The mental block I had to “just charge off the grid” was a misplaced optimism that I might get enough sunlight to make that wasteful since the cost of power is so asymmetrical in the utility’s favor. In short, if any excesss produced the utility will pay you less than 35% of what they would charge you for the same kilowatt hour.
The summer excess solar production starts as early as 1pm most days, which is fantastic.
In winter however I have to be realistic. I will never have excess solar. The sun is too low in the sky, the days are too short, it just won’t happen. Charging from the grid for 15kWh offpeak, guarantees that I don’t use any partial or on-peak power.
The winter math finally maths!
I am starting to ponder whether more solar panels or an additional grid-charged battery would be more efficient in winter..
The compulsion to optimize is enhanced by the desire to “stick it to PG&E”, probably the most hated company in California, and that’s saying something!